Published in Talent Management
Image credit by Brooke Cagle
Steven Lewis
Publisher, Editor-in-Chief, Foam
January 10, 2025
📢 How to Retain Top Talent as a Social Media Manager
Keeping top influencers requires strategy—here’s how to boost retention.
Managing social media talent isn’t just about signing great Creators—it’s about keeping them. The best Creators have options. They’re being approached by other managers, agencies, and brands who would love to poach them the second they feel undervalued, overworked, or ignored.
If you’re treating top Creators like they’re just another name on a spreadsheet, don’t be surprised when they jump ship to someone who actually prioritizes their success.
Retention isn’t about luck—it’s about building a relationship where leaving doesn’t feel like a better option. The best talent managers don’t just close deals; they make themselves indispensable.
Some managers act like glorified middlemen, showing up only when there’s a brand deal to sign and disappearing the rest of the time. That’s not a relationship—it’s a transaction. The best managers are proactive, not reactive. If the only time your Creators hear from you is when there’s money on the table, you’re already losing them. Offer value beyond deals. Coaching, content strategy, networking—anything that helps them grow. Keep communication open so they feel comfortable discussing their goals, frustrations, and expectations. If another manager offers them a better experience, they’ll leave. Make sure they don’t have a reason to.
A Creator’s biggest concern is sustainable income. If they’re constantly chasing one-off brand deals and inconsistent paychecks, they’ll start wondering if someone else could be negotiating better deals on their behalf. The best managers focus on long-term partnerships. Retainers and brand ambassadorships provide stability, while deal values should increase over time as their audience and influence grow. Smart negotiation isn’t just about taking what brands offer—it’s about pushing for higher rates, usage fees, and licensing agreements that maximize earnings. If you’re consistently landing bigger, better deals than anyone else could, why would they leave?
Brand partnerships are great—until one algorithm change tanks engagement, and suddenly, deals dry up. The best managers help Creators future-proof their income so they’re not at the mercy of platform shifts. Encouraging multiple revenue streams—subscriptions, merch, online courses, affiliate marketing—ensures financial stability. Assisting with monetization through YouTube AdSense, TikTok Creator Fund, and paid newsletters creates passive income. Expanding beyond social media into podcasting, speaking engagements, and consulting opens new career paths. Creators who feel financially secure aren’t looking for a new manager—they’re looking for new opportunities.
Top Creators aren’t just thinking about their next paycheck—they’re thinking about what’s next. If they feel like their career has plateaued under your management, they’ll start wondering who else could take them further. The best managers help them scale. Expanding onto YouTube, LinkedIn, or podcasting unlocks new revenue and audiences. Positioning them as industry leaders through speaking engagements, media features, and high-value collaborations increases their visibility. Introducing them to brands, investors, and other high-profile Creators opens the door to bigger opportunities. If they see you as a career accelerator, not just a deal broker, they’ll stay.
One of the fastest ways to lose a Creator? Messy, unclear finances. They need to know how much they’re earning, where their money is going, and what they’re actually paying you for. If there’s confusion or a lack of trust in financial dealings, they’ll start looking for management elsewhere. Transparency is key. Break down fees clearly. Show exactly what they’re paying for. Offer full visibility on payments so they always know when and how much they’re getting paid. Negotiate better payment terms with brands—chasing invoices for months is frustrating, and securing faster payment cycles keeps Creators happy. The second a Creator feels like they’re being taken advantage of, they’re already considering leaving.
Managing top Creators isn’t just about getting them brand deals—it’s about building a career, ensuring financial stability, and providing growth opportunities. The best talent managers secure better deals, help Creators build long-term income, offer clear communication and support, and ensure their Creators always feel like they’re moving forward.
Because here’s the truth: if you don’t offer all of this, someone else will.
Managing social media talent isn’t just about signing great Creators—it’s about keeping them. The best Creators have options. They’re being approached by other managers, agencies, and brands who would love to poach them the second they feel undervalued, overworked, or ignored.
If you’re treating top Creators like they’re just another name on a spreadsheet, don’t be surprised when they jump ship to someone who actually prioritizes their success.
Retention isn’t about luck—it’s about building a relationship where leaving doesn’t feel like a better option. The best talent managers don’t just close deals; they make themselves indispensable.
Some managers act like glorified middlemen, showing up only when there’s a brand deal to sign and disappearing the rest of the time. That’s not a relationship—it’s a transaction. The best managers are proactive, not reactive. If the only time your Creators hear from you is when there’s money on the table, you’re already losing them. Offer value beyond deals. Coaching, content strategy, networking—anything that helps them grow. Keep communication open so they feel comfortable discussing their goals, frustrations, and expectations. If another manager offers them a better experience, they’ll leave. Make sure they don’t have a reason to.
A Creator’s biggest concern is sustainable income. If they’re constantly chasing one-off brand deals and inconsistent paychecks, they’ll start wondering if someone else could be negotiating better deals on their behalf. The best managers focus on long-term partnerships. Retainers and brand ambassadorships provide stability, while deal values should increase over time as their audience and influence grow. Smart negotiation isn’t just about taking what brands offer—it’s about pushing for higher rates, usage fees, and licensing agreements that maximize earnings. If you’re consistently landing bigger, better deals than anyone else could, why would they leave?
Brand partnerships are great—until one algorithm change tanks engagement, and suddenly, deals dry up. The best managers help Creators future-proof their income so they’re not at the mercy of platform shifts. Encouraging multiple revenue streams—subscriptions, merch, online courses, affiliate marketing—ensures financial stability. Assisting with monetization through YouTube AdSense, TikTok Creator Fund, and paid newsletters creates passive income. Expanding beyond social media into podcasting, speaking engagements, and consulting opens new career paths. Creators who feel financially secure aren’t looking for a new manager—they’re looking for new opportunities.
Top Creators aren’t just thinking about their next paycheck—they’re thinking about what’s next. If they feel like their career has plateaued under your management, they’ll start wondering who else could take them further. The best managers help them scale. Expanding onto YouTube, LinkedIn, or podcasting unlocks new revenue and audiences. Positioning them as industry leaders through speaking engagements, media features, and high-value collaborations increases their visibility. Introducing them to brands, investors, and other high-profile Creators opens the door to bigger opportunities. If they see you as a career accelerator, not just a deal broker, they’ll stay.
One of the fastest ways to lose a Creator? Messy, unclear finances. They need to know how much they’re earning, where their money is going, and what they’re actually paying you for. If there’s confusion or a lack of trust in financial dealings, they’ll start looking for management elsewhere. Transparency is key. Break down fees clearly. Show exactly what they’re paying for. Offer full visibility on payments so they always know when and how much they’re getting paid. Negotiate better payment terms with brands—chasing invoices for months is frustrating, and securing faster payment cycles keeps Creators happy. The second a Creator feels like they’re being taken advantage of, they’re already considering leaving.
Managing top Creators isn’t just about getting them brand deals—it’s about building a career, ensuring financial stability, and providing growth opportunities. The best talent managers secure better deals, help Creators build long-term income, offer clear communication and support, and ensure their Creators always feel like they’re moving forward.
Because here’s the truth: if you don’t offer all of this, someone else will.
Continue Reading
